Score 90 or higher and you've made one. Here's exactly what the judge wants.
What earns a 10
Type: a textbook type 4, smooth and soft
Shape: one unbroken, evenly thick piece
Consistency: holds together with no cracks or soft edges
Size: the whole length of the bowl
Presentation: clean bowl, no paper, sharp photo from straight above
The ranks
90+
Golden LogThe one to aim for
80–89
EliteMuseum quality
60–79
SolidA respectable day's work
<60
Keep trainingThe judge has notes
How a score is built
The judge grades five things from 0.0 to 10.0, in tenths. Each grade is doubled into points out of 20, and the five add up to your score out of 100. 5.0 means typical.
An 8.1 is worth 16.2 points. A perfect 100 takes 10.0 in all five. A typical dump with a textbook type 4 scores about 60.
Bristol type
How close it is to the ideal smooth, soft sausage. The type (1 to 7) is still recorded separately.
GradePointsWhat earns it
10.020A textbook type 4: smooth, soft sausage
8.0–9.916–19.8Type 4 with a slight flaw, such as a few faint cracks
6.0–7.912–15.8Between type 3 and 4, or between 4 and 5
4.0–5.98–11.8Type 3 (cracked sausage) or type 5 (soft blobs with clear edges)
2.0–3.94–7.8Type 2 (lumpy sausage) or type 6 (fluffy, mushy pieces)
0.0–1.90–3.8Type 1 (hard separate lumps) or type 7 (watery)
Shape
The form only, not size or texture.
GradePointsWhat earns it
10.020One unbroken piece, evenly thick, rounded ends, no kinks, bumps or breaks
8.0–9.916–19.8One piece with one small flaw: a slight bend, bump or uneven thickness
6.0–7.912–15.8One piece with a few flaws, or two clean pieces
4.0–5.98–11.8Ordinary: one to three pieces, some bumps or uneven thickness
2.0–3.94–7.8Several broken pieces with little form
0.0–1.90–3.8No form at all: scattered bits or mush
Consistency
How well it holds together.
GradePointsWhat earns it
10.020Holds together completely: smooth surface, no cracks, no soft edges, no loose bits in the water
8.0–9.916–19.8Holds together, with one or two small cracks or a single soft spot
6.0–7.912–15.8Holds together, with several small cracks or some soft edges
4.0–5.98–11.8Mostly holds, with clear cracks or a fuzzy edge
2.0–3.94–7.8Soft and breaking apart, with many loose bits
0.0–1.90–3.8Liquid or mush
Size
Total length compared with the bowl, front to back. Coiled or in pieces counts as if laid out in a line. Thickness doesn't count.
GradePointsWhat earns it
10.020The whole length of the bowl or more
8.0–9.916–19.8About three quarters of the length
6.0–7.912–15.8About half the length
4.0–5.98–11.8About a third: a typical size
2.0–3.94–7.8About a fifth
0.0–1.90–3.8Barely visible
Presentation
The bowl and the photo.
GradePointsWhat earns it
10.020Clean bowl and water, no paper or anything else in the bowl, sharp, well lit, taken from straight above with the whole rim in frame
8.0–9.916–19.8All of that with one small flaw: slightly dim, tilted or off-center
6.0–7.912–15.8Two small flaws, or a few marks in the bowl
4.0–5.98–11.8Ordinary: some marks, or paper nearby that doesn't cover it
2.0–3.94–7.8Messy bowl, paper partly covering, or blurry
0.0–1.90–3.8Barely visible
Example
Bristol 10.0 (type 4)20
Shape 8.116.2
Consistency 7.014
Size 6.012
Presentation 9.018
Score80.2
The small print
Size is measured against your bowl. Shoot straight down with the whole rim in frame. See how to take the photo
What you see is what the judge gave. Grades aren't adjusted after the fact.
100 means perfect. Dumps scored before this rubric keep the score they were given.
Your photo isn't stored. The judge sees it once, then it's gone.